Coconut Lime Custard Pie

Serves 12 Prep Time 15 minutes   Cook Time 90 minutes   Rated:

I love the Lime Coconut flavour combo and it appears regularly throughout my many recipes. This pie was bound to happen, a version came through my inbox from one of the many recipe sites I subscribe to (for the life of me I cannot remember which) and this is the result. Their recipe was very complex and I have simplified it right down to this. You are literally making your own coconut condensed milk. So store that little fact away and pin this so you remember where to find it next time. If you are dairy free and there is a call for condensed milk, this is that!

The rest is simple. Perfect pastry (thank you) with loads of cream and that hit of lime. Just heaven.

We invite you to come join our FREE TRIAL on the Insider Club to have extra Thermomixery each and every month! #recipesthatwork #youcandoit

Are you on Instagram, Facebook, Pinterest? Never miss another thing in the test kitchen when you follow us.

Please join our mailing list HERE to have recipe updates delivered to your inbox weekly and don't forget we are on YouTube.

Our newest (FREE to Insiders) course Shelf Control sort out your pantry and fridge and is ready for your shelfies now! We have an amazing Lazy Sourdough Bakery course available to do at your own pace online. Our delicious course, The Whole Scoop Ice Cream course is churning now!




Prepare the pie crust as directed. Cool completely. Leave oven on 190°C.


To make the filling, place the coconut milk and sugar into the Thermomix bowl and cook 45 min/Varoma/speed 4/spatter guard until caramelised and sticky.


Add remaining filling ingredients to the Thermomix bowl and blend 10 sec/speed 8.


Place the baked pie shell onto a tray in the oven and pour the filling mixture into the shell. Push into the oven and bake until just set in the centre, about 40-45 minutes depending on the accuracy of your oven temp.


Transfer to a cooling rack and allow to cool completely.


Before serving, toast the flaked coconut in a hot oven for just a few minutes until well coloured. Remove and set aside.


Place the coconut cream and sugar into the Thermomix bowl and whip 10-20 sec/Butterfly/speed 4 or until soft peaks form. Stir through the finely grated lime zest using your spatula.


Top the pie in the centre with the whipped coconut cream and garnish with the toasted coconut.

More Bakery

That's all the recipes!

No more recipes to load